Review: Semuta – Thoughtless/Dreamless

Style: Sludge Metal, Post-Metal, Progressive Metal, Psychedelic Rock (Mixed vocals)
Recommended for fans of: Elder, Cave In, Russian Circles, Baroness, REZN
Country: United States (Portland, Oregon)
Release date: 9 October 2026
A few years ago, I was trying to pin down the perfect track order for a four-song EP. Starting with the best song may draw listeners in, but then you risk leaving the audience disappointed if nothing else lives up to that first track’s magic. On the other hand, saving your best for last may mean they never even make it to the end. Surely the answer is somewhere in between, right? Well, Semuta’s four-track sophomore record Thoughtless/Dreamless gave me the perfect opportunity to put my theories to the test.
Semuta’s sound is a chimeric mix of sludge, post-metal, and prog rock. Benjamin Caragol’s hefty riffs and gruff vocals combine with Ben Stoller’s killer kitwork to deliver all the power associated with the three-headed mythological beast. The duo lays Elder-esque psychedelic sensibilities overtop Russian Circles’ crescendoing textures without ever falling prey to post-metal’s pointless meanderings. The opening drum roll on “Slow Decay” is an early indicator of Stoller’s mastery of his kit. The shifting accents elevate a basic tool for any drummer into a beat that commands attention. Never happy to stay too long in one place, his thunderous tom work rumbles across the entirety of Dreamless/Thoughtless with subtle tweaks and flourishes that keep listeners on their toes. No slouch in his own right, Caragol switches from soft picking to burly chords featuring various bends and slides to keep his riffs fresh.
With the DNA of debut Glacial Erratic intact, Semuta expands its songwriting on Thoughtless/Dreamless into a seamless experience, deftly bypassing the infamous sophomore slump. In doing so, though, the band has also stripped away some of the more interesting elements of their debut, like ethereal backing vocals and the use of strings. Still, through ascending guitar runs, soaring solos and syncopated drum fills, the duo’s performance on Thoughtless/Dreamless avoids the pitfall of the distortion-heavy genres mentioned above of blending everything into a noisy soup.
As the shortest track, “A Relic” is the weakest of the four. Transitions between parts—especially into and out of the chorus—feel stitched together and lack the organic evolution of the other songs. The tempo slows for the final minute and a half, and sets up for an extended build-up into “The Well” that, while gradually increasing in intensity, broadly repeats the same lamenting riff over a sedate tom roll. The section drags for only about six minutes, before the rest of “The Well” kicks things back into gear; but with Thoughtless/Dreamless sitting at a trim 37 minutes total, it’s hard to gloss over. Like the middle book of many a trilogy, this minor sag serves as a bridge between the opening interest and a (hopefully strong) conclusion, without leaving much of its own impression. But holy hell, the ending is worth the wait.
Drawing from Caragol’s struggle with insomnia, the title track opens with beefy chords ringing out over stunning cymbal swells. Caragol’s vocals grow more dynamic, moving from the traditional doomy affect of Lord Mountain’s Jesse Swanson to later adding a little extra snarl. Semuta cultivates a growing sense of desperation through constant tempo changes before dropping an absolute bomb of blast beats and proper capital-G growls akin to Anciients. The passage injects some great energy into the song, but feels somewhat out of place with it being a singular event on Thoughtless/Dreamless. Managing to pull off this aggression so effortlessly, though, is a testament to the pair’s versatility, and I’d love to see them explore that side of their sound more in future releases.
So has Semuta cracked the track order code? Thoughtless/Dreamless proves there’s merit to the idea of saving your best for last, but only when the rest of the material also stands up to scrutiny. The album easily flies by in a single sitting and knowing what awaits me at the end has kept me coming back to the well time and again. Yet, in writing such a smooth record, and despite their inspired musicianship, Caragol and Stoller never stray too far away from the confines of their sound’s overarching genres. Getting a bit more experimental with their components may just be what pushes Semuta into creating an even more lethal brew.
Recommended tracks: Thoughtless/Dreamless, Slow Decay
You may also like: Abrams, Anciients, Boss Keloid, Solothurn, Somnuri
Final verdict: 7.5/10
Related links: Bandcamp | Facebook | Instagram
Label: Accident Prone Records
Semuta is:
– Benjamin Caragol (Vocals, guitars)
– Ben Stoller (Drums)
0 Comments