Review: Thomas Miller’s Lazarus Effect – Thomas Miller’s Lazarus Effect

Published by Ian on

Album art “by”1 Rodrigo Gudiña

Style: Progressive Metal, Power Metal (clean vocals)
Recommended for fans of: Symphony X, Myrath, Circus Maximus, Michael Romeo
Country: United States (New Jersey)
Release date: 30 Oct 2026


Having recently published a full ranking of their discography, it’s no secret that we at the Subway have had Symphony X on the brain as of late. Since 1994, these New Jersey legends have been blending meat-and-potatoes Dream Theater prog metal with heaping helpings of Malmsteen-style neoclassical cheese and high-octane power-metal spice, and a key portion of their sound’s original recipe was bassist Thomas Miller. With his distinctly crackly, high-treble tone and emotive lyric writing, he was a key architect of classic albums like The Divine Wings of Tragedy before abruptly departing in 1999 due to touring-related fatigue. Over the following fifteen years,2 Symphony X would evolve in a decidedly heavier, more meatheaded direction, and fans who preferred the sensitivity of their old-school style would sometimes look back at those first albums and wonder if this change would have happened had Miller not left. Of course, the man had at that point fully retired into obscurity, leaving such questions to mere speculations and whispers… until now. Indeed, after decades spent outside the public eye, the six-string bass slinger himself has seemingly come back from the dead with the appropriately-titled Thomas Miller’s Lazarus Effect. Can he successfully bring that vintage sound back out of the ashes,3 or are some things better left buried?

From the very first pompous, faux-orchestral flourishes of opener “Dark Horse”, it is immediately obvious that Miller isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel. The Lazarus Effect is a project completely and utterly dedicated to reconstituting that vintage Symphony X sound, from its burly odd-meter riffs to its harmonic-minor melodies to frontman Howard Portney doing his absolute best to channel early Russell Allen’s soaring, gritty bravado. Miller even reunites with some of his old bandmates, with the Michaels (Romeo and Pinnella) contributing guitars and keyboards respectively, and both lay down performances like they just stepped through the looking glass from 1998. Romeo, especially, seems to be having a ball, fluently sweeping and shredding through one sick-as-hell solo after another while dusting off his charmingly plasticky programmed orchestras and choirs from the turn of the century to lend everything a warm, nostalgic sheen. Add in Miller’s little flourishes of “lead bass” delivered with his trademark dry tone, alongside a mix and master from original SX producer Eric Rachel, and you have an undeniably authentic blast from the past, with ambitious, accolade-worthy compositions like “Closer to the Sun” sounding almost as if they were taken from an alternate-reality version of V where Allen left the band instead of Miller.

Of course, try as the Lazarus Effect might to pick up where Twilight in Olympus left off, not every musical relic from that era can be reproduced to perfection. The most obvious difference comes, of course, from one “Hollywood How” Portney on vocals. Don’t get me wrong, he’s an extremely solid metal vocalist in his own right, and he’s certainly not nearly as pitchy as original SX frontman Rod Tyler could get at times. Still, though… he’s no Russell Allen. While, as I said earlier, he evokes the grittier, Dio-esque side of Allen reasonably enough, he can’t quite match the buttery-smooth tone and emotional vulnerability of his predecessor’s softer moments, which keeps otherwise-emotive cuts like “All the King’s Horses” from feeling as haunting as they should be. Despite this, Portney does establish his own identity beyond mere masquerade, most notably in his piercingly high classic-metal banshee wails that are put to impressive use throughout the album, and any fans who prefer the heavier side of SX but without the excess “tough-guy” attitude that marred later albums will find a lot to like in his performances. 

The songwriting, too, has its share of sins and shadows. While Romeo seems more than happy to step out of his dragon’s den of DAWs and ever-spiraling writer’s block so he can just play guitar while Miller handles all the composition, the simple fact of the matter is that Miller just isn’t quite as inventive a writer of riffs as Romeo is. While the likes of “Fear No Evil” and “When Darkness Falls” certainly get the job done, they lack the rapid-fire intricacy and creativity that made Symphony X so exciting, falling more towards workmanlike classic metal tropes than the flashy smoke and mirrors of Romeo’s best work. At other points, the compositions can get a bit too authentic—those early albums were sometimes marred by jarring, awkward transitions, and tracks like “Culmination” unfortunately keep that tradition alive by lurching from one movement to the next in a way that results in the whole feeling less than the sum of its parts. Still, when the writing is on, it’s on, with the aforementioned “Closer to the Sun” and closing epic “Sailing to Utopia” jam-packed with stirringly emotional choruses, kickass solos on three instruments, and enough rapturously retro compositional flourishes to forgive the record’s more painful moments.

Overall, whether the Lazarus Effect successfully brings back the magic of that old SX sound isn’t a question that can be answered with a simple “yes” or “no”. With the wait for a proper new album from the band seemingly stretching to the edge of forever, it’s natural for fans to be searching for something to scratch that itch, and Miller’s return certainly serves that purpose. However, while it does come about as close as an album reasonably can to recreating that vintage sound three decades on, said sound wasn’t exactly as consistent in quality as some fans’ nostalgia goggles may lead them to believe, and in that regard Miller might have resurrected more than he bargained for. At times, the Effect soars through Heaven on divine wings of past glories, at others it struggles through the damnation of uneven writing and uninspiring riffs. In the end, then, I suppose its final fate is not black or white, but left in shades of grey—hopefully it can serve as a premonition of greater things to come when Symphony X finally returns for real.


Recommended tracks: Fear No Evil, Closer to the Sun, Sailing to Utopia
You may also like: Adagio, Eternity’s End, Sunburst
Final verdict: 6.5/10

Related links: Bandcamp | Facebook | Instagram

Label: Laser’s Edge

Thomas Miller’s Lazarus Effect is:
– Thomas Miller (bass, songwriting, orchestration)
– Howard “Hollywood How” Portney (vocals)
With guests
:
– Michael Romeo (guitars, programming)
– Michael Pinnella (keyboards on “Closer to the Sun” and “Sailing to Utopia”)

  1. I’m not usually one to put scare quotes next to artist credits, but given how slop-ish this cover looks, and given how the same “artist” is also credited as the “prompt engineer” on a transparently AI-generated music video for the project, I highly doubt that Mr. Gudiña was the sole “artist” for this cover, if you catch my drift. I fully believe that Miller wrote and produced the music side of things without any AI input (otherwise that final score would be a hell of a lot lower), but it’s disappointing to see him signing off on it for the visuals nonetheless. ↩︎
  2. The decade after that, unfortunately, was marked by the band not releasing anything at all, with the constant financial pressures of touring combining with Michael Romeo’s ever-worsening musical perfectionism to inflict their promised new album with a neverending litany of delays. Maybe we get something in 2027, who knows. ↩︎
  3. There are references to 16 different ’90s-era Symphony X songs in this review. Can you find them all? ↩︎

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *